Tax considerations when funding and de-funding US subsidiaries of Indian groups
Contents
Indian groups often fund a US subsidiary to support market entry, acquisitions, working capital, talent or product development. However, the funding instrument selected at the outset can also determine how efficiently capital may eventually be returned to India.
Principal repayments, interest, dividends, redemptions, sale proceeds and liquidation distributions can have different US tax and withholding consequences. These consequences should be considered alongside the applicable Indian tax, foreign exchange, transfer pricing and corporate law requirements.
Funding should therefore be structured around the business purpose, expected cash flow profile, downside scenarios, and eventual exit route. It should not be treated as a one-time remittance.
Funding choices: aligning form with economics
Common equity is generally regarded as the most resilient form of loss-absorbing capital. It avoids a fixed servicing obligation during the built-out phase and is generally the most defensible instrument where repayment depends on uncertain future profits. Its limitation, however, is the relative inflexibility in the return of capital.
A later payment to the Indian parent is not automatically a tax-free recovery of invested capital. Under the US earnings-and-profits ordering rules, a corporate distribution is generally treated as a dividend to the extent of current or accumulated earnings and profits, then as a reduction of stock basis, and only thereafter as a gain.
A board resolution describing a payment as a 'return of capital' does not, by itself, determine its US federal income-tax treatment. Records relating to the capital contributions, stock basis, and earnings and profits should therefore be maintained from inception.
Preferred equity can combine features such as liquidation preference, cumulative return, conversion rights or a stated redemption date. However, these features do not guarantee tax-efficient repayment.
If the Indian parent remains the sole or controlling shareholder after a redemption, the transaction may fail to qualify for sale-or-exchange treatment under IRC section 302. It may instead be treated under IRC section 301, resulting in dividend treatment to the extent of earnings and profits.
Redemption premiums, increasing redemption prices and certain conversion adjustments or disproportionate distributions may also create deemed distributions under IRC section 305.
Revenue Ruling 66-37, 1966-1 Cumulative Bulletin 209 illustrates that the redemption of a parent corporation's preferred stock may be governed by IRC section 301 where the parent retains control of the subsidiary through its common stock. Accordingly, the tax treatment of preferred stock should be modelled across issuance, accrual, redemption and withholding rather than characterised as 'debt-like' solely because it carries a fixed return or redemption feature.
Example: An Indian parent owns all common and preferred stock of its US subsidiary. It invests USD 4 million in preferred stock, which the subsidiary subsequently redeems USD 5 million, while the parent retains all the common stock. If the IRC section 302 requirements are not met and the subsidiary has sufficient earnings and profits, the full USD 5 million, not merely the USD 1 million premium, may be treated as a dividend under IRC section 301.
Debt provides a contractual mechanism for principal repayment and may generate a US interest deduction. The deduction, however, is only one part of the analysis.
Indicators of a credible loan include:
Unconditional repayment obligation
Fixed or determinable maturity
Arm’s-length terms
Adequate borrower repayment capacity
Credible creditor rights
Servicing in accordance with its terms
Consistency with the documents
IRC section 385 allows debt characterisation to turn on substance rather than label. Relevant factors include a written unconditional promise to pay, maturity, subordination, repayment source, leverage and the relationship between stock ownership and instrument holdings. Excessive leverage, repeated extensions, profit-dependent repayment or deep subordination may indicate equity investment. However, no single factor or universal debt-to-equity ratio determines the outcome. Treasury Regulation section 1.385-3 may also treat certain expanded-group debt as stock, including instruments connected with specified distributions, stock acquisitions or asset reorganisations, subject to the applicable exclusions and exceptions.
Even debt that is respected for US tax purposes may not produce an immediate deduction.
IRC section 267(a)(3) may defer deductions for interest owed to a related foreign person until the amount is treated as paid under the applicable rules.
The business interest limitation under IRC section 163(j) may defer the deduction of interest expense, with any disallowed amount generally carried forward to future taxable years, subject to the applicable limitation. Thus, legally valid debt may still fail to produce the expected current tax benefit.
Other relevant considerations include the transfer pricing rules under IRC section 482, which require arm's-length pricing and permit IRS adjustments, and IRC section 267A, which may disallow deductions arising from hybrid mismatch arrangements.
Treaty and beneficial-ownership requirements, state interest add-back rules and potential base erosion and anti-abuse tax (BEAT) implications under IRC section 59A may also need to be considered. Such financing arrangements may also trigger Form 5472 reporting obligations for a foreign-owned US corporation.
A parent guarantee can strengthen debt by improving financing terms for a subsidiary with independent repayment capacity. If a thinly capitalised subsidiary is unable to borrow independently and the lender relies principally on the parent for repayment, the financing may be viewed as borrowing by the parent and a corresponding equity contribution to the subsidiary.
The cases illustrate that the debt-versus-equity analysis turns on the economic substance of the financing arrangement and the surrounding facts, rather than on the existence of a shareholder guarantee alone. In Murphy Logging Co. v. United States,[1] the court considered the broader economic circumstances of the borrower, including its operating business and valuable contractual relationships. By contrast, in Plantation Patterns, Inc. v. Commissioner[2]the court upheld the treatment of shareholder-guaranteed notes as an indirect capital contribution in circumstances involving a thinly capitalised corporation. The resulting equity characterisation meant that the corporation was not entitled to the claimed interest deduction.
Accordingly, the debt-equity analysis focuses on the borrower's business assets and operations, capitalisation, ability to support the borrowing independently and the extent to which the lender relies on the shareholder's credit support.
Where the purported debt is recharacterised as equity, the corporation may lose the related interest deduction, and payments on the instrument may instead be treated consistently with an equity investment.
[1] Murphy Logging Co . v. United States, 378 F.2d 222 (9th Cir. 1967) [2] Plantation Patterns, Inc. v. Commissioner, 462 F.2d 712 (5th Cir. 1972), affirming Tax Court Memorandum 1970-182
The overlooked inflexion point: restructuring the debt
Tax analysis often focuses on the initial funding decision, while the consequences of a subsequent workout receive less attention.
Under Treasury Regulation section 1.1001-3, a significant modification of a debt instrument is treated as a deemed exchange of the existing debt for a modified instrument. As a result, what may appear to be a 'commercial amendment' can constitute a tax transaction even without cash payments.
A modification is defined broadly and may arise through:
A written or oral amendment
A waiver
The parties' conduct
Alteration of legal rights
Relevant tests include economically significant changes in yield, material deferral of scheduled payments, changes in the obligor, security or recourse, and changes that cause the instrument to cease to qualify as debt. Related amendments should be tested together rather than in isolation.
Modification area
Why it matters
Yield
Generally significant when annual yield changes by more than the greater of 25 basis points or 5% of the original annual yield of the unmodified instrument (Treasury Regulation section1-1001-3(e) (2)(ii))
Payment timing
A material deferral of scheduled payments is generally significant, unless it falls within the applicable safe-harbour period. The safe-harbour period begins on the original due date of the first deferred payment and extends for the lesser of five years or 50% of the instrument's original term. (Treasury Regulation section 1.1001-3(e)(3))
Obligor, security or guarantee
Obligor: A change in the obligor on a recourse debt is generally significant unless an exception applies. For non-recourse debt, a substitution is generally not significant. Addition or deletion of a co-obligor is significant if it changes payment expectations. Treasury Regulation section1.1001-3(e)(4)(i)-(iii)
Security or guarantee: Adding, releasing or changing collateral or a guarantee is significant if it changes payment expectations. For non-recourse debt, a substantial change in collateral is generally significant. (Treasury Regulation section 1.1001-3(e)(4)(iv))
Change between recourse and non-recourse status
A change from recourse to non-recourse, or vice versa, is generally significant, subject to specified exceptions, including certain changes where the instrument remains secured by the original collateral and payment expectations do not change. (Treasury Regulation section 1.1001-3(e)(5)(ii))
If the change in interest rate is made by operation of the terms of the original instrument (such as an automatic reset), it is generally not treated as a modification unless it falls under specific exceptions.
A deemed exchange can create cancellation of debt (COD) income if the modified debt's issue price is below the old debt's adjusted issue price, subject to IRC section 108.
It may also create original issue discount (OID), which could affect the timing of future interest deductions. Accrued interest, fees, hedges, withholding, reporting and state tax positions may also need to be reassessed. Payment holidays, maturity extensions, rate or currency changes, guarantee releases and distressed refinancings should therefore undergo a tax reissuance review before signing.
Example: An Indian parent holds a USD 10 million note issued by its US subsidiary. A material maturity extension, payment deferral and rate reduction result in a significant modification. If the debt is publicly traded and has an issue price of USD 8.5 million based on the modified instrument's fair market value, the US subsidiary could recognise USD 1.5 million of COD income, subject to the applicable rules under IRC section 108.
If the modified debt remains payable at USD 10 million, it may also give rise to USD 1.5 million of OID, potentially resulting in deductions over the term of the instrument, subject to the applicable limitations. The result is not automatic. If neither instrument is publicly traded and the modified debt provides for adequate stated interest, section 1274 may instead produce an issue price equal to the USD 10 million stated principal amount. In that case, the modification may constitute a deemed exchange without producing either COD income or OID. Thus, a liquidity-driven workout may accelerate income, defer deductions, or create no immediate income, depending on the applicable issue-price rules.
Conclusion: build the exit into the entry
Cross-border funding decisions shape not only how capital enters a US business but also how it can eventually be returned, refinanced, or restructured. The right structure should reflect the subsidiary's underlying economics, preserve available deductions, withstand debt-equity scrutiny and provide a credible route for capital to return to India.
For Indian groups funding US operations, that may mean combining permanent equity with appropriately sized debt rather than asking one instrument to serve every purpose. The objective is to preserve flexibility as the business evolves, without creating avoidable tax leakage.
Priyanka Mehta, Director and Dhruti Biswas, Manager, US Tax, Grant Thornton Bharat has also contributed to this article.
The article first appeared in the Taxsutra on 12 November 2026.
Learn more about how our US Tax Services services can help you
The US Tax Insights provides a curated overview of significant federal and state tax developments, key IRS guidance, notable judicial decisions, and practical planning considerations relevant to businesses and individuals.
The tax and regulatory environment continues to evolve rapidly, with significant developments on both federal and state fronts. To keep you ahead of these developments, we present the October 2026 edition of the Grant Thornton Bharat Monthly US Tax Bulletin.